Skip to content

Two Blows to China’s Rare Earth Monopoly

July 7, 2011

I’m just getting my feet back under me here in Beijing after a two-week business trip to the US.  In coming days, I’ll be posting a link to the video of my speech on the “Beijing Consensus” (once it’s up) and sharing some thoughts about the troubling consequences of China’s awkward approach to monetary tightening, as well as offering some perspective into the complex nature of inflation.  But in the meantime, two news stories caught my eye, related to China’s efforts to gain political and economic leverage from its near-monopoly on rare earth minerals, which I highlighted last year.

Story #1:  On Tuesday, the World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled that China had “violated global rules by restricting exports of nine raw materials used in the manufacturing of high technology products.”  The petition — filed by the US, EU, and Mexico in 2009 — did not cover rare earth minerals, but the restrictions that were struck down are nearly identical to the rules Beijing later applied to rare earths.  In particular, the WTO rejected the central Chinese claim that “its [export] restrictions were motivated by a desire to protect the environment and prevent a critical shortage of the materials” (presumably because the proper, non-discriminatory approach to such concerns would be to restrict production, not exports; export restraints appear to favor domestic industry to the disadvantage of foreign users).  Since that is precisely the rationale given for Chinese restrictions on rare earth exports, the decision is expected to pave the way for a successful European challenge to those rules.  If China has legitimate environmental or conservation goals in respect to rare earth mining, the ruling suggests, cutting off foreign buyers and supplying only Chinese users is NOT an acceptable approach.

Story #2:  Alarmed by China’s cut-off of rare earth supplies last Fall, the Japanese responded by doing exactly what I predicted they would do:  search for alternative sources of supply.  According to a British scientific journal, it appears they have found one.  The Japanese say they have found vast — and readily accessible — deposits of at least some rare earth minerals on the seabed in international waters in the Pacific Ocean, near Hawaii and Tahiti (I say at least some because there are 17 rare earth elements, each with distinct applications and processing methods, and all “rare earth deposits” are not created equal in terms of the distribution of these various minerals).  Of course, mining the seabed raises its own environmental dilemmas, but the point is, rare earth minerals aren’t really that rare, it’s just that China offered such a cheap source that nobody bothered to go looking for any.  But that cheap source was only attractive so long as it was reliable; when that reliability was called into question, buyers were willing to pay a bit more to hunt around for a steady alternative.

The two stories, combined, appear to deflate concerns (or hopes, as the case may be) that China would be able to exercise a “stranglehold” over the market for these critical industrial ingredients.  And it shows how fleeting — and ultimately futile — efforts to engineer a monopoly in any dynamic marketplace must prove to be.

2 Comments leave one →
  1. Rider I permalink
    July 8, 2011 2:52 am

    However, Why would the WTO appeals court try and justify the worlds biggest non market economy and its centralized planning entity the SASAC as a not a non market enity. When they where the one’s who have centralized the worlds jobs and taxes along with 97% of the worlds resources to their non market activities. Specifically due to pin point placement of WTO and World Bank economic leadership of their MSS espionage agents. Which the MSS is now expanding their bases and trying to seek more espionage seats.

    Rider I


  1. China Radio: Rare Earth WTO Challenge « Patrick Chovanec

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: